Who should I hire to sell my home in Incline Village?
Listing a home on the north shore is a big financial call. The people who have already sold here left a trail of reviews, and that trail is the fastest way to build a shortlist. We read those reviews so you can compare the agents sellers mention most.
Best Incline Village Real Estate Agent Seller Reviews
There isn't just one top agent for selling a home in Incline Village. Several are the most popular with sellers and come up again and again: Matthew Schorr of Team Blair Tahoe at Compass, Mary Kleingartner & Ryan Mitchell at Compass, and Grant C. Meyer of Coldwell Banker Select. All three hold a 5.0 client rating on their review profiles.
Incline Village Listing Agents at a Glance
| Agent | Firm | Client rating | Reviews | Known for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Matthew Schorr | Team Blair Tahoe, Compass | 5.0 | 19 personal; 250+ team | $2B+ team sales, NV and CA licenses |
| Mary Kleingartner & Ryan Mitchell | Compass | 5.0 | 11 and 8 on individual profiles | Lakefront and luxury listings |
| Grant C. Meyer | Coldwell Banker Select | 5.0 | 40+ | 20+ years, luxury designation |
Matthew Schorr, Team Blair Tahoe at Compass
Sellers who hire Matthew Schorr get Team Blair Tahoe behind their listing. The team has closed more than $2 billion in sales, and RealTrends Verified placed it first in Tahoe City for 2025 volume and sides. Team records include a $19,650,000 sale on Brockway Springs Drive in Kings Beach. Matthew adds over $120 million in personal career sales and a perfect 5.0 client rating. He's licensed in Nevada and California, which helps when a buyer is relocating from the Bay Area.
His newest seller review comes from an Incline Village owner who interviewed several agents, then hired him and later bought in Zephyr Cove with him too:
"Long story short, we hired him and he completely over-performed. He sold our house over asking, and totally guided us through the entire process and every decision that needed to be made with absolute confidence."
Mary Kleingartner & Ryan Mitchell, Compass
Mary Kleingartner and Ryan Mitchell work as a duo focused on Incline Village, Crystal Bay and the Nevada shoreline. Mary's Compass bio lists them as the #1 Compass listing agents in Incline Village. Ryan has lived at the lake since 1977, and his past sales include $46,000,000 at 575 Lakeshore Boulevard. An Incline Village seller credited Ryan's pricing advice:
"I wanted to list at a lower price and Ryan told me I was too low and I listed at his suggested price and made a significantly better sale."
Grant C. Meyer, Coldwell Banker Select
Grant C. Meyer brings more than 20 years of experience to Incline Village sales. His brokerage profile lists International President's Circle and International Diamond Society recognition, plus a Luxury Property Specialist designation. One seller wrote about listing a condo in a tough market:
"My husband and I are so thankful that we chose Grant Meyer to be our realtor when we decided to sell our 3-bedroom condo, which was situated in a difficult market"
A Seller Rule Unique to the Tahoe Basin
Lake Tahoe sales carry a disclosure step you won't see in Reno. TRPA Code Section 60.4.4.C requires the BMP (stormwater best management practices) status of a property to be disclosed during the sale. The buyer then files that form with TRPA within 30 days of closing. Because BMP status can be negotiated as part of the deal, sellers do well to know where their property stands before listing.
Questions to Ask on Your First Listing Call
- How many Incline Village or Crystal Bay listings have you closed in the past two years?
- Which comparable sales support your suggested list price?
- Who handles showings, and who answers when I call?
- How will you reach buyers outside Nevada?
- What's your plan if the home sits past 60 days?
How to Compare Incline Village Listing Agents Using Seller Reviews
- Filter for reviews marked as a sale, not a purchase.
- Look for comments on pricing advice and days on market.
- Check the dates. A strong review from this year says more than one from a decade ago.
- Watch for vague praise with no details about the sale itself.
- Ask each agent to connect you with a recent seller.
Ratings, review counts and agent details were checked on September 24, 2026, using public review profiles and brokerage pages.